Although
you may regularly monitor sales and profit figures, doing so without
knowing how much your business is worth in today's market is comparable
to looking only at your portfolio's earnings without knowing your
portfolio's overall worth.
Just as
investment decisions should be geared toward maximizing the value of
your portfolio, the same criteria should apply to decisions that affect
your small business.
Most small
business owners realize the importance of knowing their companies' worth
during major transitional periods such as mergers and acquisitions,
shareholder buyouts and initial public offerings. However, every major
business decision you make has the potential to affect the value of your
company.
Have you
ever thought about relocating to more modern facilities, upgrading your
technology, expanding your product line or changing your management
team? If so, knowing the current value of your business will help you to
more accurately predict what the impact of such actions is likely to be.
Are
professional valuations necessary?
When asked,
small business owners regularly over- or under-estimate the value of
their companies by as much as 50 percent - which is understandable given
the complexity of the valuation process.
Although no
single formula can realistically estimate the value of your business,
there are some basic variables that can be applied in most situations.
These include current market conditions and the company's stock value,
earnings history, financial condition and future earnings capacity.
However, even these basic components may not be as simple as they appear
because they deal with numerous complicated factors (such as supply and
distribution contracts, tangible and intangible assets as well as
pending legal and regulatory issues, among others).
Professional valuation firms - some of which specialize in serving small
to medium-sized businesses - have the resources and experience to
collect and interpret this essential information.
Valuation options
Different
types of business valuations feature different levels of complexity. As
a small business owner, the type that's best for you probably will
depend on why you're having the valuation prepared.
If you're
preparing a valuation for tax and estate planning purposes, a "59-60"
appraisal may be the best option. Based on IRS Revenue Ruling 59-60, the
IRA standard for estate and gift tax purposes, a 59-60 valuation
compares a privately held company to public companies in the same or a
similar line of business and then applies a lack of marketability
discount or a control premium.
If you're
preparing a valuation for a specific proposal such as a sale, merger or
acquisition, though, you'll probably need a more detailed appraisal
tailored specifically to the proposal. In general, transactional
appraisals will require more time and money than 59-60 valuations
because of the additional factors, such as products, management and
competitors, to be examined.
Regardless
of which type of valuation you need, it should be updated on a regular
basis. If you review your business plan once a year, consider updating
your business valuation at that time. Doing so will help you to evaluate
the effectiveness of last year's business decisions and may even offer
some insight into the year ahead. And remember, your business decisions
- like the decisions that affect your portfolio - always should be
geared toward maximizing the value of your investment.
Although
frequently overlooked, current valuation is an extremely useful tool for
the small and midsize business owner.
By
George M. Noceti in the August 29, 2005 East Bay Business Times
George M. Noceti is a financial adviser with
Morgan Stanley in Walnut Creek.